Thursday, May 26, 2005

Politicians are Not Public Servants

Politicians have big egos. That’s the astounding conclusion of Peggy Noonan’s editorial in today’s Wall Street Journal.

Actually, once she gets past bashing the filibuster compromisers for their immodesty, she makes a good point. Which is why I’ve posted on it. She ends up with:

I think everyone in politics now has been affected by the linguistic sleight-of-hand, which began with the Kennedys in the 1960s, in which politics is called "public service," and politicians are allowed and even urged to call themselves "public servants." Public servants are heroic and self-denying. Therefore politicians are heroic and self-denying. I think this thought has destabilized them.

People who charge into burning towers are heroic; nuns who work with the poorest of the poor are self-denying; people who volunteer their time to help our world and receive nothing in return but the knowledge they are doing good are in public service. Politicians are in politics. They are less self-denying than self-aggrandizing. They are given fame, respect, the best health care in the world; they pass laws governing your life and receive a million perks including a good salary, and someone else--faceless taxpayers, "the folks back home"--gets to pay for the whole thing. This isn't public service, it's more like public command. It's not terrible--democracies need people who commit politics; they have a place and a role to play--but it's not saintly, either.

Generally, we could all use a little more humility. Our leaders even more so.


At 3:36 AM, Blogger Andrew said...

A GOOD Politician IS a public servant. A good politician balances his/her constituents needs with national needs, and works tirelessly for a good cause; in some cases making changes that better society. the problem is, most politicians today are NOT public servants - they look after their constituents only to the extent that it will get them re-elected, so they can use their power to get more for themselves and their network


Post a Comment

<< Home